* Please note this replaces the previously announced episode for this date and time.

AFTER J.T. AND GRANT BOTH POP THE QUESTION AT SHELLY'S BIRTHDAY PARTY, SHE STRUGGLES TO DECIDE WHO SHE WANTS TO MARRY, ON A REBROADCAST OF "EVE," ON A SPECIAL DATE AND TIME, TUESDAY, JAN. 24 AT 8:30 PM ON UPN

Sharif Atkins ("ER") Guest Stars as Grant

"How Will I Know?" -- After J.T. and Grant (guest star Sharif Atkins) both dramatically propose to Shelly at her birthday party, she must weigh the qualities -- and engagement rings -- of both men in order to decide who she wants to marry and build a future with, on a rebroadcast of EVE, on a special date and time, Tuesday, Jan. 24 (8:30-9:00 PM, ET/PT) on UPN. Mary Lou Belli directed the episode from a script written by David W. Duclon & Walt Kubiak. (Originally broadcast 9/22/05)

Meanwhile, after skipping his flight back to England and staying in the U.S. illegally, Donovan shows up on J.T. and Nick's doorstep, looking for help as he decides what to do next with his life.

Shelly Williams: Eve
J.T. Hunter: Jason George
Rita Lefleur: Ali Landry
Janie Egins: Natalie Desselle-Reid
Nick Delaney: Brian Hooks
Donovan Brink: Sean Maguire
Grant: Sharif Atkins

RATING: TVPG-L